Hiking Boots vs Hiking Shoes: What Are the Differences?

This post is sponsored by adidas. All content and opinions are my own.

When exploring the outdoors, I encourage you to follow Leave No Trace Principles and be respectful of where you are so we can preserve these spaces for future generations. ♥️

One of the biggest dilemmas of my hiking career? Deciding whether or not I wanted to pull on a pair of hiking boots or hiking shoes for hitting the trail. Personally, I have always had problems with my ankles, which has meant that the support from hiking boots has been necessary. However, there are some definite trade-offs for choosing the heavier option.

Hiking shoes definitely have their strengths too–they’re more water resistant and if you are taking on a thru-hike or a long backpacking trip, they can keep you from getting too worn out over long distances. Plus, there’s almost no break-in time.

In this article, we’ll go over the benefits and downsides of choosing boots or shoes, and why you might want to choose one over the other. There are no right or wrong answers–you need to choose the option that works best for you.

In summary: This article will go over the benefits of choosing hiking boots over hiking shoes and visa versa. We’ll cover some of the pros of each so you can find the footwear that works best for your next hike.

Quick tip: Any time you are thinking about purchasing hiking footwear, I recommend heading to a local gear store. They can also help you find the type of socks that will work with whatever type of footwear you end up choosing,

Differences between hiking boots and hiking shoes

When I first started hiking more seriously, I found myself totally confused about what should go on my feet. Should I invest in a pair of hiking boots like the ones my dad wore on our family trips to Yellowstone, or would trail runners be better for the kinds of hikes I wanted to do? Over time, I’ve tried just about every option out there, and I’ve learned that the main differences come down to a few key factors.

Hiking boots typically offer more ankle support, which I’ve found super helpful on rocky terrain or when carrying a heavier pack. They’re usually more durable and water-resistant too. On the flip side, hiking shoes are lighter weight, which means less fatigue on longer hikes. I notice the difference especially at the end of a long day on the trail—my feet aren’t as tired in shoes. 

Boots take longer to break in, while shoes tend to be comfortable right out of the box. The trade-off is that shoes generally don’t last as long as a good pair of boots.

How to choose between hiking boots and hiking shoes

Choosing between boots and shoes really comes down to knowing your hiking style and the conditions you’ll face. I usually almost always go for my hiking boots unless I am climbing and know I will need to carry a pair of approach shoes with me.

If you’re like me and tend to hit varied terrain or hike in unpredictable weather, consider what kind of support your ankles need. I have relatively weak ankles even after years of hiking, so hiking boots are my go-to. However, there have definitely been longer backpacking trips where I wish I had a lighter-weight option

Your pack weight matters too. If you’re carrying more than 20-25 pounds, boots might serve you better. For day hikes with just water and snacks, shoes are often just fine as an option. And don’t forget about your planned pace—if you like to move quickly or even mix in some trail running, shoes are definitely the way to go. 

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer, which is why my gear closet has gradually accumulated several options for different adventures!

Types of hiking boots

Hiking boots come in several different varieties, and it took me a few purchases to figure out which ones were right for me. The type you choose really depends on what kind of hiking you plan to do most. 

When I first got serious about hiking, I went straight for heavy-duty backpacking boots—which was overkill for the day hikes I was mostly doing! Learn from my mistakes and consider which category best matches your outdoor activities.

Day hiking boots

These are typically most hikers’ first choice for trail adventures. They’re typically mid-height and provide enough ankle support for day hikes or overnight trips with a lighter pack. I have a pair that I sometimes wear if I know that I’m not taking on anything too intense—they’re comfortable enough that I don’t notice them, but protective enough for those rocky sections. They strike that perfect balance between weight and support.

Backpacking boots

For multi-day hikes where you are carrying a lot of weight, these heavier boots are absolutely essential. They’re designed for trips when you’re carrying a substantial pack. The stiffer midsoles and more robust ankle support saved my feet on those long trekking days. While they’re heavier, that extra stability is worth it when you’re far from the trailhead with a full pack.

Mountaineering boots

I’ve only needed true mountaineering boots a handful of times, like when I climbed Cotopaxi in Ecuador. These are the tanks of hiking footwear—extremely rigid, often crampon-compatible, and built for harsh conditions. They’re overkill for most hiking, but when you’re dealing with snow, ice, or serious elevation, they’re irreplaceable. In many cases, they’re also required for expeditions.

Types of hiking shoes

As my hiking style has evolved over the years, I’ve found myself reaching for hiking shoes more often, especially for quick day hikes near home. There’s something liberating about how lightweight they feel compared to boots! I initially resisted the switch, thinking I needed the ankle support because of weak ankles.

But after trying trail runners for some easier hikes close by, I was amazed at how much more agile I felt on the trail. Like boots, hiking shoes come in several varieties, each with its own specific purpose.

Barefoot or minimal shoes

These ultra-lightweight shoes have almost no cushioning and a zero-drop design, meaning your heel and toe are the same distance from the ground. While they do make you feel more connected to the trail, you will have to condition your feet for longer hikes.

Trail-running shoes

These have become my absolute favorite for spring and summer day hikes under 10 miles. They’re basically beefed-up running shoes with better traction and protection. The breathability is a game-changer in hot weather, and they dry so much faster than boots when crossing streams—something I appreciate after too many soggy-boot experiences!

Approach shoes

I added these to my collection when I got more into rock climbing. They’re a hybrid between climbing shoes and hiking shoes, with sticky rubber soles and reinforced toe boxes that excel on rocky terrain. I use mine for hikes in places like Squamish where scrambling is involved. The precision they offer on technical terrain is impressive, though they’re not as comfortable for long-distance hiking as my trail runners.

Join the community! Love the outdoors? Join my free Facebook community where we chat and share information about national parks, hiking, outdoor activities, and more! JOIN HERE!

Tips for deciding between hiking boots or hiking shoes

Here are some tips I’ve found helpful for picking out the type of hiking footwear I need for my next adventure.

• Know your terrain: Rough terrain will require having a thicker midsole in order to protect your feet, which means you’ll want to choose hiking boots in this instance. Likewise, if you are on a fairly even trail, then you should be able to get away with soles that are thinner.
• Consider your budget: Typically, hiking boots tend to be more of an investment and pricer than trail runners or other hiking shoes. This is usually due to the fact that hiking boots are composed of more material. If you plan on hiking a lot, then boots might be worth the investment since they tend to last longer. However, if you are only planning a few day hikes a year, then trail runners might be the best option for your budget.
• Support or weight: You will likely have to decide whether or not you want the additional weight when and support that come with hiking boots compared to the lightweight option of trail runners. Do keep in mind that trailrunners will not likely provide the same support, especially in the ankles.
• Know how long your hike will be: How long your hike will be can be a determining factor in whether or not hiking boots or hiking shoes are the best option. Most often, backpacking boots are what you will choose when it comes to multi-day hikes since they hold up better, but many thru-hikers swear by trail runners since they are lighter weight.

Hiking boots vs hiking shoes FAQs

Here are some common questions I get from readers about whether or not they should choose hiking boots or shoes.

Conclusion

I hope this has helped you narrow down whether or not you want to choose hiking boots or hiking shoes for your next adventure. Most importantly, finding the right option for you is definitely a personal choice–every avid hiker has their own type of shoe that works for them. I would recommend being open and trying a few types of shoes if you can so you can find what works for you.

Have any questions about choosing whether hiking boots or hiking shoes are right for you? Let me know in the comments!